<< GORE CONSENSUS DISPUTED ~ MAIN ~ BOOK CLUB >>

PROTEST NOVEL PUBLISHED SOMEHOW

Gregory Day reviews Andrew McGahan’s Underground, a “protest novel written out of a sense of disgust with the political and moral direction of the Australian Government” featuring the characters Leo James (twin brother of the evil Prime Minister, Bernard James) and Aisha, a “fierce blonde strangeling” with terrorist organisation Great Southern Jihad:

They trigger a mass execution of Muslim refugees in the NSW outback, they are selflessly ferried across the Murray River at night by a female Aboriginal elder, they wind up in a walled compound for Muslims on Sydney Road called the Brunswick Ghetto - which is bombed by government aircraft - necessitating their flight through an underground tunnel. And from there they head to Canberra for what can only be described as the book’s mega-denouement.

It is a sickening indictment of the “coalition of the willing” era that that this fluorescently far-fetched plot is almost plausible.

(Via Tony Thomas)

UPDATE. Hanyu: “And why did I know Gregory Day would be a first-class compassionate head tilter?”

Posted by Tim B. on 10/27/2006 at 10:45 PM
  1. Maybe Messieurs Day and McGahan should run the ALP’s election campaign next year.

    Posted by entropy on 2006 10 27 at 10:50 PM • permalink

  2. "Through it all Leo James reflects on a different Australia of years gone by, when politicians had spines, when the population was expert at bullshit-detection, when we could fight wars without losing all sense of who we were. “

    FMD, if you don’t know who you are see a therapist rather than write some deranged pap in an attempt to find your place in the world.

    Posted by Harry Buttle on 2006 10 27 at 10:54 PM • permalink

  3. It is a sickening indictment of the “coalition of the willing” era that that this fluorescently far-fetched plot is almost plausible.

    To a fuckwit (tautology alert) Age columnist perhaps.

    Posted by Craig Mc on 2006 10 27 at 10:59 PM • permalink

  4. The opening paragraph from the review linked above reads:

    Imagine the hyperbolic narrative techniques of Dan Brown being employed to convey the political opinions of David Marr.

    I laughed so hard I couldn’t read the rest. If the book is as funny as the review, then count me in. It sounds great.

    Posted by Hanyu on 2006 10 27 at 11:02 PM • permalink

  5. yeah, I’ll run right out and get this one.

    On the other hand, I got an email saying this had been sent to me. At least it’s an author we can trust.

    [Long url to Arthur Chrenkoff’s book on Amazon removed because it was breaking the page. Go to Amazon.com and use the “search” function if you want to find it. The Management.]

    Posted by debi L. on 2006 10 27 at 11:07 PM • permalink

  6. I reckon I’ll wait for the movie version.

    Posted by Harry Bergeron on 2006 10 27 at 11:10 PM • permalink

  7. And why did I know Gregory Day would be a first-class compassionate head tilter.

    Posted by Hanyu on 2006 10 27 at 11:10 PM • permalink

  8. Sheesh! A “Detective Paco” story is more plausible than this junk.

    Posted by paco on 2006 10 27 at 11:16 PM • permalink

  9. Exactly how much LSD is Gregory Day consuming daily?

    Posted by Crispytoast on 2006 10 27 at 11:16 PM • permalink

  10. Hanyu’s head-tilter is an eyebrow furrower, to boot. And there’s more:

    "He is also a poet and, with his partner Sian Marlow, publishes limited edition books....
    He’s....recorded a solo album, Black Tower, which set several of William Yeats’ poems to music. The songs attracted the attention of the Yeats Society...”

    Yikes, there’s a fellow to reckon with !

    Posted by Harry Bergeron on 2006 10 27 at 11:22 PM • permalink

  11. And from there they head to Canberra for what can only be described as the book’s mega-denouement.

    Where Leo launches his army of pacifist gay whales, and giant papier-mâché heads at the facsists’ tanks, while Aisha applies for a grant to conduct goddess poetry courses.  The battle drags on, fortunately Leo & Aisha don’t have to go back to their Marxist Finger-Painting degree until semester starts - and even then there’s only three contact hours.

    However, activists, whales and damp newspaper are no match for an enemy that isn’t surgically attached to a bong and the fascists prevail.  They immediately hold an election and are returned with an increased majority.

    Aisha dumps Leo - a woman can’t be expected to work with something that tiny - and marries his brother.  He has a job after all.  Aisha & Bernard now have three sons: Bernard Jr., Ronald, and Dubya.

    Posted by Craig Mc on 2006 10 27 at 11:22 PM • permalink

  12. What’s this about bombing Brunswick, I live near there?  Almost plausible, hey that’s good enough for me, I’m selling up and going.

    Posted by spyder on 2006 10 27 at 11:25 PM • permalink

  13. Way OT, but

    St.Louis Cardinals 2006 World Champions

    Go Cards

    Posted by rinardman on 2006 10 27 at 11:29 PM • permalink

  14. FMD, if you don’t know who you are see a therapist rather than write some deranged pap in an attempt to find your place in the world.

    I don’t know who he is either, but whoever he is, he sounds like a dickhead to me.

    Posted by AlburyShifton on 2006 10 27 at 11:34 PM • permalink

  15. OT as well, but saw this at Jihad Watch (Vote Early and often!) just now.  Our Prime Minister John Howard has been nominated by the Islamic Human Rights Commission as Islamophobe of the Year........okay Bush and Blair got a mention tooooooo.

    If you want to vote, and I think you should, the only thing to decide is vote ‘no one’ or go for it and see who we can get to win!

    Posted by spyder on 2006 10 27 at 11:36 PM • permalink

  16. Predictable ain’t it? If its a conservative, or christian, or if it doesn’t have the usual head tilting slant towards the left’s ratbag of policies- anti-American, anti-Jew, anti- capitalistic, anarchy, “refugees”, the Age will usually lambast it or praise it to high heaven.  Anyhow else remember the bloody awful reviews that the Age gave to HBO’s Rome, and Narnia?

    Posted by Wylie Wilde on 2006 10 27 at 11:40 PM • permalink

  17. ...publishes limited edition books....

    Code for vanity publishing. In other words, his work is such crap that he has to pay to get it printed.

    Might get the book, though, when it is remaindered tomorrow. The outdoor dunny needs paper after vast sales only exceeded by Lowenstein’s. Are the pages as absorbent as a koran’s?

    MarkL
    canberra

    Posted by MarkL on 2006 10 27 at 11:41 PM • permalink

  18. PIMF

    Might get the book, though, when it is remaindered tomorrow after vast sales only exceeded by Lowenstein’s. The outdoor dunny needs paper.

    MarkL
    canberra

    Posted by MarkL on 2006 10 27 at 11:47 PM • permalink

  19. #13: Opens the dreaded “Black Book”. Hands trembling with psychopathic rage, writes in the name, “rinardman.” Laughs maniacally, closes book, returns it to safe hidden behind picture of Kirk Gibson hitting home run in the last game of the 1984 World Series. Bides time . . .

    Posted by paco on 2006 10 27 at 11:50 PM • permalink

  20. #16:
    "Anyhow else remember the bloody awful reviews that the Age gave to HBO’s Rome"

    WHAT! Now they’ve really ticked me off.

    Posted by AussieJim on 2006 10 28 at 12:02 AM • permalink

  21. Maybe it’s just me, but after following Hanyu’s link and reading the story about the eels, my first reaction was to think “Gosh, I hope they didn’t go to waste.”

    I’m off to find a snack…

    Posted by Not My Problem on 2006 10 28 at 12:10 AM • permalink

  22. Paco...can’t...can’t we all just get along....

    Posted by rinardman on 2006 10 28 at 12:24 AM • permalink

  23. My hovercraft has eels.

    Posted by guinsPen on 2006 10 28 at 12:25 AM • permalink

  24. #9 Crispytoast.Surely it wouldn’t be acid! Totally inorganic don’t y’know.The politically correct and truly delightful psilocybian fungi will however provide a similar level of detachment from reality.A particular favorite,well regarded for its alkaloid content,is the dung inhabiting species,panaeolus cyanescens.It is recommended that one does not ingest the host just stick to the mushroom otherwise one could finish up full of shit.

    Posted by Lew on 2006 10 28 at 12:29 AM • permalink

  25. I went and voted for hoWARd as the “Islamophobe of the Year”. (several dozen times)

    While buggering up their nasty little poll, I was sniggering at the ratbag’s title “ Islamic Human Rights Commission”

    Islam? Human Rights?  In the same breath? Hohohohohohoho.

    Posted by Pedro the Ignorant on 2006 10 28 at 12:31 AM • permalink

  26. Protest novel, huh? Well, he’s going to regret this speaking truth to power when the thugs bust down his door and he’s pinned to the floor with jackboots on his neck.

    I mean that IS going to happen, right?

    Posted by Shaky Barnes on 2006 10 28 at 12:35 AM • permalink

  27. I have never heard of Andrew McGahan, but I do wonder if he has a brother called David.

    Posted by Nilknarf Arbed on 2006 10 28 at 12:42 AM • permalink

  28. i’m surprise charles johnson of littlegreenfootballs fame wasn’t nominated as Islamophobe of the Year.

    Posted by drscroogemcduck on 2006 10 28 at 12:55 AM • permalink

  29. We note that Gregory Day is the author of The Patron Saint of Eels, published by Picador.

    Please be advised that the Eels in that instance are nothing to do with the honourable and mighty Parramatta football club known as the Eels.

    Posted by Rafe on 2006 10 28 at 01:34 AM • permalink

  30. It is a sickening indictment of the “coalition of the willing” era that that this fluorescently far-fetched plot is almost plausible.

    Almost? Almost?  Darn...and I love the smell of bombed ghetto in the morning.  Or is that Gekko?

    Posted by trainer on 2006 10 28 at 01:53 AM • permalink

  31. I’m sorry, call me an economically minded, cold hearted son of a bitch if you wish, but why would we drop bombs on them?  If they’re trapped in this ‘ghetto’, why not just turn off the water and lob in a few white phosphorus grenades?  London 1666 anyone?

    We’d save SHITLOADS on the weapons alone, forget jet fuel, flight pay and aircraft maintenance.

    Also could the great and powerful Andrea please fix that page format thingy?  Cheers.

    Posted by The_Wizard_of_WOZ on 2006 10 28 at 02:17 AM • permalink

  32. Gregory Day, Age book reviewer, is socuddly

    Posted by percypup on 2006 10 28 at 03:13 AM • permalink

  33. It is a sickening indictment of the “coalition of the willing” era that that this fluorescently far-fetched plot is almost plausible.

    The unintentionally hilarious plot line of A Handmaid’s Tale is more “plausible” than this nonsense. Good grief.

    Posted by Spiny Norman on 2006 10 28 at 03:22 AM • permalink

  34. Both of these guys are obviously highly educated.

    Posted by saltydog on 2006 10 28 at 03:30 AM • permalink

  35. My hovercraft has eels.

    But do eels have hovercrafts?

    Posted by ekb87 on 2006 10 28 at 03:48 AM • permalink

  36. The text is full of bald sermonising and broad-brush stereotypes that are found in most airport thrillers. It is also dotted with adjectival blandness, unauthentic language (no “born and bred” Hawthorn supporter would call a guernsey a “jersey") and curiously touristic depictions of a landscape that McGahan has described far better in the past.

    But wait!

    McGahan has chosen a style that facetiously mirrors his content.

    The cunning bastard!

    And there was me thinking that the book was just plain shithouse. All praise to The Age for explaining such brilliance to the unsophisticated masses!

    Posted by ekb87 on 2006 10 28 at 03:58 AM • permalink

  37. In related news, David Marr is honest enough to rubbish another left-wing GWOT thriller by a more literary kind of writer.

    Posted by Andrew R on 2006 10 28 at 04:35 AM • permalink

  38. Whaddya expect from someone who played for Fitzroy....

    Posted by crash on 2006 10 28 at 04:56 AM • permalink

  39. #37 That’s one of the best reviews of a novel I have ever read! People must hav been knocking the doors down at Collins this morning to make sure they get a copy.  The review is almost as long as most of the novels I have ever read too (like one of Nick Earls’ characters in Bachelor Kisses, I am an affectionado of thin novels). 
    I particularly liked the flourish Marr uses to finish off the review:

    Who could do anything but wish it well and hope that what’s not achieved on the page can be realised on the screen: a fine, imaginative grappling with the manipulation of fear in the late Howard era.

    Who could argue with that? 

    What a tosser.

    Posted by entropy on 2006 10 28 at 04:59 AM • permalink

  40. off topic,. but could Antony Lowenstein and the Wendy Lowenstein obituarised below by Andrew Bolt be related? Just wonderin’.

    The Age compass goes haywire over schoolgirl sex
    By Andrew Bolt
    Thursday, October 26, 2006 at 10:40am

    The Age obituary page gives teacher, historian, author and former communist Wendy Lowenstein a tender farewell:

    Teaching at a high school in the 70s, Wendy caught a group of schoolgirls selling their favours to passing businessmen. Instead of admonishing them, she lectured them on the values of unionism, agreeing on a base rate and never undercutting their fellow worker because that was tantamount to ‘scabbing’. (One of the girls was charging 50c to do what the others were getting $2 for).

    Meanwhile The Age editorial gives us a stern sermon on the evils of a video shot by Werribee schoolboys having sex with a possibly willing, although vulnerable, school girl and then monstering her despicably:

    But the wiser and more effective course is to fine-tune our ethical compass for the promising, sometimes frightening, journey ahead.

    Tune away, Mr Jaspan.

    Posted by percypup on 2006 10 28 at 05:47 AM • permalink

  41. #39 Yeah, I said he was honest enough to attack the book. A complete examination of conscience was never likely.

    Posted by Andrew R on 2006 10 28 at 06:16 AM • permalink

  42. Imagine the hyperbolic narrative techniques of Dan Brown being employed to convey the political opinions of David Marr.
    Sorry. You lost me right there.

    Posted by blogstrop on 2006 10 28 at 07:08 AM • permalink

  43. Percypup, if I recall from reading that post and comments on bolta’s blog, Wendy is richard Lowenstein’s mother or sister. No relation to Antony at all.

    Posted by Nilknarf Arbed on 2006 10 28 at 11:51 AM • permalink

  44. It is a sickening indictment of the “coalition of the willing” era that that this fluorescently far-fetched plot is almost plausible.

    It is a sickening indictment of the condition of today’s left that this fluorescently far-fetched (great description there) kind of “literature” is just so much wishful thinking.

    Posted by RebeccaH on 2006 10 28 at 12:08 PM • permalink

  45. Have to agree with Mark L at #17

    “Limited Edition” = lack of demand.

    His songs have attracted the attention of the Yeats Society.  I bet. As is ‘cease and desist order”.

    Posted by yojimbo on 2006 10 28 at 12:52 PM • permalink

  46. Jesus Fucking H. Christ, what a monumental piece of crap that books sounds.  And his previous one won the Ned Kelly?

    I had no idea some lout in a tin can who robbed people of their money also wrote high-toned lefty-style craparama.  That Ned Kelly, he was multi-talented.

    Posted by ushie on 2006 10 28 at 01:33 PM • permalink

  47. #7. Hanyu, heal-tilt indeed. What about the purple shirt, the signature piece of self-hating men wimps.

    Posted by JAFA on 2006 10 28 at 02:54 PM • permalink

  48. Heal head-tilt.

    Posted by JAFA on 2006 10 28 at 02:55 PM • permalink

  49. "head-tilt”

    I can’t figure out how leftys manage the HEAD-TILT OF CONCERN thing.  They have no backbones...so, how come their heads don’t flop onto their shoulders when they tilt?

    Posted by Dave Surls on 2006 10 28 at 05:07 PM • permalink

  50. Oh, man, you guys should read the excerpts of Jim Webb’s novels on Drudge.  I didn’t know whether to laugh or scream.

    How DOES a stripper slice a banana with her vagina, anyway?

    Posted by ushie on 2006 10 28 at 05:31 PM • permalink

  51. the Brunswick Ghetto - which is bombed by government aircraft - necessitating their flight through an underground tunnel

    Apart from its startlingly original allusion to Warsaw, it makes me more terrified of Moslems -
    they’re undermining Australia

    Posted by Barrie on 2006 10 28 at 06:36 PM • permalink

  52. How in the world did we allow such faggoty wankers to thrive? I wish I could put Day, McGahan and Marr in a wooden tub and send them on a fact finding tour of gay whales in the South Pole.

    Posted by Wylie Wilde on 2006 10 28 at 06:37 PM • permalink

  53. #15 Our Prime Minister John Howard has been nominated by the Islamic Human Rights Commission as Islamophobe of the Year........okay Bush and Blair got a mention toooo.

    Funny, isn’t it, that three countries that put their non-Moslem soldiers in harms way daily to stop vicious Islamic tribes tearing each other apart, are against their Islamic Human Rights

    Posted by Barrie on 2006 10 28 at 06:44 PM • permalink

  54. Compared with the new Bush Snuff Movie - out just in time for the elections! - this is pretty mild. 
    The American Left have excelled themselves, but they had to get a Pom director to do it.

    His pathetic defence:  Gratuitous gross violence in a film about a major current leader is merely cinematic entertainment, and no-one would dream of relating it to real life ... besides, it DOESN’T CONDONE THE ASSASSINATION in any way!

    I call this the “Reverse Spielberg Defence”

    Posted by Barrie on 2006 10 28 at 06:52 PM • permalink

  55. Bleurgh, how embarrassing. Andrew McGahan is a relative of mine. I guess I shouldn’t expect any better. Some other choice quotes from said family include:
    “Stop global warming!”
    “I voted for the Greens,”
    and
    “The Mufti’s comments were only published to incite racial tensions.”

    Posted by Fiona on 2006 10 29 at 12:50 AM • permalink

  56. From what I’ve seen, the plot could be too mainstream for his target audience.

    Posted by Big Jim on 2006 10 29 at 02:32 AM • permalink

  57. And Fiona, I sympathise.  They are everywhere.  Like the proverbial homosexuals, we all know one or have our lives touched by one.  You should see some of the Christmas dinner ‘conversations’ over at the Big Jim house…

    Posted by Big Jim on 2006 10 29 at 02:37 AM • permalink

  58. (When the eels came out) it was like, OK, the locals can only know so much; they’ve only been here so long. What if someone came along that really knew?"

    Well, sport, you should have gone to the library and done some research.  Could’ve saved yourself years of wondering about if and when the sky was going to fall.

    The eels weren’t committing suicide as lemmings are thought to do, but don’t.  Nothing ailed them.  They were exhibiting normal eel migration behaviour.

    Dill!

    Posted by Janice on 2006 10 29 at 02:53 AM • permalink

  59. "They trigger a mass execution of Muslim refugees in the NSW outback"

    Er...so why did the Muslim refugees come to Al-Straya if it was so hostile to Muslims?

    Then again, in reality they’ve been coming for decades to this hostile place .  Obviously we need a better communication plan

    Posted by PeterTB on 2006 10 29 at 03:37 AM • permalink

  60. I had no idea some lout in a tin can who robbed people of their money also wrote high-toned lefty-style craparama.  That Ned Kelly, he was multi-talented.

    Actually, he did!

    Posted by Mr Hackenbacker on 2006 10 29 at 08:32 PM • permalink

  61. “The Mufti’s comments were only published to incite racial tensions.”

    And the Mufti made them ... why?

    Posted by Achillea on 2006 10 30 at 12:00 PM • permalink

  62. Page 1 of 1 pages

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.

Members:
Login | Register | Member List

Please note: you must use a real email address to register. You will be sent an account activation email. Clicking on the url in the email will automatically activate your account. Until you do so your account will be held in the "pending" list and you won't be able to log in. All accounts that are "pending" for more than one week will be deleted.